Minor league data suggests robot umpires reduce strikeouts on breaking pitches
Whiff rates on curveballs and changeups fell in the Pacific Coast League after hitters gained the right to appeal checked-swing calls.
By Robert Ward ·

Batters in the Triple-A Pacific Coast League missed fewer breaking and offspeed pitches this year after gaining the ability to challenge checked-swing calls using Major League Baseball's Automated Ball-Strike Challenge System. The change resulted in a measurable decrease in swing-and-miss rates for those specific pitch types.
From May 5 through the end of the season, the whiff rate on curveballs, sliders, sweepers, and knuckleballs dropped by 2.6 percentage points. The rate fell even more sharply on changeups, splitters, and screwballs, declining by 3.6 percentage points. In games where the challenge system was active, batters appealed 0.25 checked-swing calls per game and succeeded in overturning the umpire's decision 55.5% of the time. The overall whiff rate in those games decreased from 25.3% to 24.1%.
These results stand in contrast to the performance of hitters in the Triple-A International League during the same period. Umpires in that league were instructed to use the 45-degree threshold for defining a swing, but teams could not appeal the calls. The overall whiff rate in the International League dipped slightly from 23% in 2025 to 22.9% in 2026. Fastball whiff rates in the Pacific Coast League remained largely stable, moving from 19.4% the previous year to 19.3% this season.
The ambiguity of the current rulebook drives the push for a clearer standard. Official Baseball Rules define a strike as a legal pitch that is struck at and missed, without specifying the mechanics of a swing. The Automated Ball-Strike Challenge System defines a swing as occurring when the angle between the bat head and the handle exceeds 45 degrees. This metric aligns with the geometry of the foul lines, offering a binary standard for umpires and players.
Front office executives view the change as a correction to a long-standing frustration. Mike Hazen, general manager of the Arizona Diamondbacks, stated that he dislikes the art of calling a check swing. He noted that historical footage from the 1950s and 1960s shows full swings that were often ruled as holds, describing the old practice as bananas. Brandon Gomes, general manager of the Los Angeles Dodgers, suggested the 45-degree angle might need slight modification to avoid looking like old Sandy Koufax-era footage where full swings were questionable.
Managers also weighed in on the definition. Pat Murphy, manager of the Milwaukee Brewers, pointed to a specific incident in World Series Game 2 involving Tampa Bay Rays player Yandy Diaz. Murphy believed Diaz did not swing until video review showed the bat barrel past the front of the plate. He acknowledged that while it was hard to see in real time, the slow-motion replay confirmed the swing.
Strikeout rates in Major League Baseball have risen steadily over the past two decades, increasing from 16.4% of plate appearances in 2006 to 23.9% in the most recent completed season. The rate hit a record 27% in 2022 before settling slightly after the pitch clock was installed in 2023. The strikeout rate was nearly identical in 2025 and 2026, a period that saw the implementation of the Automated Ball-Strike Challenge System for standard ball-strike calls.
Baseball Commissioner Rob Manfred has indicated that any major league adoption of the checked-swing review system would not occur until 2028 at the earliest. The experiment began in the Arizona Fall League in 2024 and moved to the Class A Florida State League in 2025. New York Yankees pitcher Gerrit Cole, the 2023 American League Cy Young Award winner, argued that the sport needs to stabilize after recent rule changes. He expressed concern about disrupting a successful implementation of the current ball-strike challenge system.






