Appeal in Lindsay Clancy Case Advances to Massachusetts Supreme Court
A retired judge suggests the recent legal development could complicate future trials for the mother accused of killing her three children.
By News Media House Staff ·

Lindsay Clancy, a Massachusetts mother accused of murdering her three young children in 2023, has achieved a significant procedural step in her legal battle. On Thursday, the state's Supreme Judicial Court accepted the case for review after the appeal was referred to the full court by Justice Elizabeth Dewar. Legal experts describe this move as a modest but meaningful victory for the defense team.
The appeal centers on a motion to dismiss the case on double jeopardy grounds. Clancy's attorneys previously filed this request with Justice Dewar following Judge William Sullivan's denial of their earlier motion. By referring the matter to the full court, the justices have set briefing deadlines for next month and scheduled oral arguments for January. This development occurs while jury selection for the retrial is already planned to begin on March 29.
Jack Lu, a retired Massachusetts judge and legal scholar, characterized the decision as a small win for the defense. He warned, however, that the appeal has the potential to unravel the framework for future trials. Lu noted that the legal terrain remains difficult and unforgiving, arguing that the defendant's position could interfere with jury deliberations in subsequent cases and present an unworkable system for handling complaints from deliberating jurors.
The original trial concluded on September 4 with a hung jury after one week of deliberations. A single juror, Michael Desronvil, voted to find Clancy guilty, while the rest of the panel leaned toward acquittal. The defense argued that Desronvil should have been dismissed and replaced by an alternate juror after the foreperson claimed he was failing to apply the standard of reasonable doubt correctly.
In his initial ruling, Judge Sullivan expressed skepticism regarding the foreperson's accusation. He found that a manifest necessity existed to declare a mistrial because the jurors were unable to reach a unanimous verdict. Sullivan issued a 17-page order earlier this month, maintaining that the decision to declare a mistrial was justified despite the defense's objections.
Desronvil has maintained in post-trial interviews that the evidence clearly demonstrated Clancy's guilt. He specifically cited the playback of Patrick Clancy's 911 call as a pivotal moment that convinced him the mother had methodically planned the deaths of her children, Cora, 5, Dawson, 3, and Callan, 8 months.
Clancy, who was 36 at the time of the incident, did not dispute strangling the children with exercise bands on January 24, 2023. Her defense team argued that she was suffering from postpartum psychosis and should not be found guilty due to a mental disease or defect. Prosecutors, conversely, alleged that she planned the slayings, sent her husband out to run errands, and killed the children before he returned home.
The father, Patrick Clancy, discovered his then-wife seriously wounded in the yard and their three children in the basement upon his return. Clancy later attempted to jump from a second-story window in a failed suicide attempt, which left her paralyzed. The case has drawn significant attention to the complexities of double jeopardy claims in retrials.
Carol Erskine, another retired judge and child welfare advocate, noted that securing review by the full Supreme Judicial Court is rare. She stated that such appeals typically require exceptional circumstances, such as constitutional rights being at stake or urgent issues that cannot wait for the ordinary appellate process. During her own career, she filed three such appeals, with only one succeeding.
As the legal process moves forward, the outcome of the appeal could set important precedents for how hung juries and juror disputes are handled in high-profile criminal cases in Massachusetts.
Originally published by News Media House
More News · National news · Report a business · Got a Story?





