MLB Teams Ranked by Likelihood of Signing Skubal
An analysis of the 2026 free agent market assesses the odds for all 30 clubs to land ace pitcher Tarik Skubal, alongside realistic backup strategies for each organization.
By News Media House Staff ·

Tarik Skubal stands out as the premier acquisition in the 2026-27 Major League Baseball free agent class. The two-time Cy Young Award winner has maintained a 2.42 earned run average over the last three seasons, making him a clear difference-maker in what is otherwise considered a weak group of available players. With a projected contract value potentially reaching $300 million, his availability has prompted a detailed evaluation of which clubs have the financial and strategic capacity to sign him.
The current landscape of pitching presents a unique challenge. While starters throw harder than ever with advanced breaking balls, filling 162 starts has become increasingly difficult. In 2026, 377 different pitchers started a game, averaging 12.6 per team. Only Michael Wacha reached 200 innings, a stark contrast to 2016 when 15 pitchers achieved that milestone. This scarcity elevates the value of an elite starter like Skubal, though a new labor deal could alter the financial dynamics of such a contract.
The assessment divides the 30 teams into tiers based on their probability of signing Skubal. Tier 5 represents teams with virtually no chance, typically small-market franchises with owners reluctant to spend heavily. The Colorado Rockies, for instance, have not signed a premium free agent starter since Mike Hampton in 2001. Their backup plan focuses on affordable options like Zac Gallen to fill rotation spots left by recent one-year deals.
The Oakland Athletics also fall into this lowest tier. Since signing Mark McGwire and Ruben Sierra in 1993, the A's have been hesitant to commit to large contracts, signing only two free agents to bigger deals since then. Their likely alternative is Shota Imanaga, fitting a pattern of overpaying for mid-rotation starters. Similarly, the Cincinnati Reds need to replace Hunter Greene, who is out for the season due to Tommy John surgery. Given their franchise history, they are more likely to target Kris Bubic or Dustin May than Skubal.
The Miami Marlins and Kansas City Royals also show limited interest in a massive signing. The Marlins, under Bruce Sherman, have rarely exceeded $36 million for a free agent, making a closer like Raisel Iglesias a more probable priority than a starter. The Royals, who ranked 25th in ERA last season, may look to Chris Bassitt or Kevin Gausman. Both are cost-effective options that could provide a boost without straining the payroll, unlike the high-cost pursuit of Skubal.
Tier 4 includes teams where a Skubal signing is unlikely but not impossible. The Pittsburgh Pirates, with a current payroll estimated at $129 million, could theoretically afford him if a new salary floor of $180.2 million is implemented. However, they are more likely to add a veteran swingman like David Peterson to support Paul Skenes and Bubba Chandler. The Los Angeles Angels, awaiting a new era under owner Stan Kroenke, may prioritize bullpen upgrades over a marquee starter, given their lack of winning records since 2015.
The Washington Nationals have significant payroll space and a need for rotation help, making them candidates for high-profile non-Skubal signings like Freddy Peralta or Kaima Taira. The Baltimore Orioles, despite a solid rotation, must replace departing free agents Trevor Rogers and Chris Bassitt. They are likely to target veterans such as Kevin Gausman or Tyler Mahle, who fit into a projected salary range of approximately $50 million over three years.
The Atlanta Braves might dream of pairing Skubal with Chris Sale and Spencer Strider to evoke past dynasties, but their history suggests they favor extensions over massive free agent deals. Sonny Gray, a Tennessee native, represents a more realistic and cost-effective target. Meanwhile, the San Francisco Giants, coming off a 65-97 season, face rotation issues that may require spreading resources among several players rather than committing to one ace. They may pursue options like Freddy Peralta or Clay Holmes to address their deficiencies.
The Texas Rangers, who made massive signings before the 2021-2022 lockout, face a tighter budget this year. With limited payroll flexibility, they may look to trade players like Corey Seager or Jacob deGrom to clear space. A realistic move would be re-signing Tyler Mahle, who offers an upgrade over current options. Tier 3 teams, such as the Milwaukee Brewers and Seattle Mariners, may not need a starter as urgently. The Brewers have depth and may focus on locking up William Contreras, while the Mariners could trade Logan Gilbert to address bullpen needs, potentially targeting Bryan Abreu or Pete Fairbanks.
The Philadelphia Phillies will continue to rely on their core group of starters, including Cristopher Sanchez and Zack Wheeler. With limited depth beyond these five pitchers, their strategy remains focused on maintaining stability rather than making a splashy addition. This tiered approach highlights the varying priorities and financial realities facing each franchise in the upcoming offseason.
Originally published by News Media House
More News · National news · Report a business · Got a Story?






